Sunday, September 1, 2013
Ashley (Managing E-Learning): Behaviourism, Constructivism and Connectivism Theo...
Ashley (Managing E-Learning): Behaviourism, Constructivism and Connectivism Theo...: Learning Theories The Behaviourism theory “ dictates what knowledge the learners will learn, in what order they will learn it and how it i...
Sunday, August 25, 2013
| « Word of the Week: Communication, Communication, Communication | Leadership with Impact: A Framework for Academic Development » |
Blended Learning is Like Teenage Sex
The title of this blog entry is borrowed from the sustainability literature and more specifically the opening remarks made by Joel Mackower during Compostmodern '08. Mackower's comparison between sex and sustainability initiatives was presented at the outset of a seminar today on inter-disciplinary initiatives in this area at Michigan State University.
The comparison got me thinking about whether the original quote could be adapted to apply equally to the concept of blended learning. What do you think? Here is the adapted quote:
"Blended learning is like teenage sex. Everybody says they're doing it but no one really is. And those who are doing it aren't doing it very well."
There are some interesting similarities. Some people argue that blended learning is nothing new and people have been doing it for a long time. On the other hand, I would argue that blended learning is still a poorly defined concept and the literature is immature. How do you know that you're doing it when there are different meanings and understandings of what it actually involves. And of course even if lots of people are doing it there is a reasonable chance of disappointment. Arguably, perfecting the art of blended learning requires a lot of experience, a skilled teacher and it does help if you have the right equipment.
I'll stop on this note before totally risking my reputation for serious academic critique. Nevertheless, feel free to extend the comparison in your own thinking as I'm sure other people can be far more creative than me. At very least the teenage sex analogy is likely to grab attention and generate interesting debate. Enough said!
To raise the quality of the conversation, I would also like to alert readers to Graham's (2011) recent critique of the Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK) Framework in the journalComputers & Education. This Framework has become popular around the world in the context of technology-enhanced learning and the paper makes a valuable contribution to the literature by critically reviewing TPACK against criteria for theory building. Graham concludes that 'considerable theoretical work still needs to be done if TPACK research is to cohere and constructively strengthen the field of educational technology' (p.1953).
I encourage you to read the full paper as it reminds us of the dangers of embracing popular educational concepts, theories and perspectives (including blended learning) without adequate critique and debate. Hopefully these comments in a small way will contribute to deeper conversations of whether blended learning is really a disruptive influence to traditional forms of pedagogy. Time to stop as I sense another comparison with teenage sex coming...
Reference
Graham, C. (2011). Theoretical considerations for understanding technological pedagogical content knowledge (TPACK). Computers & Education 57 (3), 1953–1960
Trackback address for this post
Feedback awaiting moderation
This post has 1206 feedbacks awaiting moderation...
Comment feed for this postLeave a comment
Wednesday, August 14, 2013
Awareness: Osho on how to Stop Thinking
Awareness: Osho on how to Stop Thinking: Question: I have been Thinking all day of a way to ask the Question: How to stop thinking? Osho : THINKING cannot be stopped. Not that...
Sunday, August 4, 2013
Friday, July 19, 2013
My Inner Journey: Osho - Women's Breats
My Inner Journey: Osho - Women's Breats: OSHO comments on Sankara’s sutra: ‘Do not be infatuated by the beauty, the breasts, the navel and the waistline of a woman’ Man is a...
Monday, July 15, 2013
teaching english method: GRAMMAR TRANSLATION METHOD
teaching english method: GRAMMAR TRANSLATION METHOD: A. BACKGROUND OF GRAMMAR TRANSLATION METHOD The first concern with language teaching method had to do with the teaching of Lati...
Wednesday, March 27, 2013
Official Google Reader Blog: Welcome, Google Apps users!
Official Google Reader Blog: Welcome, Google Apps users!: Posted by Brian Shih, Product Manager Google Apps recently launched an improvement that made dozens of exciting Google services available ...
Official Google Reader Blog: Upcoming changes to Reader: a new look, new Google...
Official Google Reader Blog: Upcoming changes to Reader: a new look, new Google...: Posted by Alan Green, Software Engineer In the next week, we’ll be making some highly requested changes to Google Reader. First, we’re goi...
Official Google Reader Blog: New in Reader: a fresh design, and Google+ sharing...
Official Google Reader Blog: New in Reader: a fresh design, and Google+ sharing...: Posted by Alan Green, Software Engineer Today we're rolling out the new Reader design, and the Google+ features that we mentioned just...
Official Google Reader Blog: Powering Down Google Reader
Official Google Reader Blog: Powering Down Google Reader: Posted by Alan Green, Software Engineer We have just announced on the Official Google Blog that we will soon retire Google Reader (th...
Tuesday, March 26, 2013
Thursday, March 21, 2013
ICT in ELT WARWICK 2012: LEARNING CHOCOLATE
ICT in ELT WARWICK 2012: LEARNING CHOCOLATE: Welcome to the Learning Chocolate Vocabulary Learning Platform! What is it? What does it do? It is a creative website where the can...
ICT in ELT WARWICK 2012: MYBRAINSHARK
ICT in ELT WARWICK 2012: MYBRAINSHARK: http://www.brainshark.com/mybrainshark What is it? / What does it do? This is the easiest way of putting your presentations up on the...
ICT in ELT WARWICK 2012: LinoIT
ICT in ELT WARWICK 2012: LinoIT: What is it and what does it do? Give it a shot! Linoit is a web-based software used in the same way like the sticky notes we already ...
Free Technology for Teachers: About the Author
Free Technology for Teachers: About the Author: Contact me via email at richardbyrne (at) freetech4teachers.com About the blog: The purpose of this site is to share information about...
ICT in ELT WARWICK 2012: FREETECH4TEACHERS
ICT in ELT WARWICK 2012: FREETECH4TEACHERS: What is it? What does it do? This is a Blog written by Richard Byrne, who is providing for FREE resources for teaching and learning. His ...
ELT ICT ELT ICT ELT ICT ELT ICT ELT...: miss my blog
ELT ICT ELT ICT ELT ICT ELT ICT ELT...: miss my blog: i miss my blog. i am in China. usally cannot open my blog.
ICT Reflections: Cute ICT in ELT blog
ICT Reflections: Cute ICT in ELT blog: Using ICT in teaching English as a second or foreign language: news, information and updates at http://www.ictinelt.com by Elek Máthé from...
ICT in ELT Jo Gakonga: Fodey.com - Make your own newspaper
ICT in ELT Jo Gakonga: Fodey.com - Make your own newspaper: This site is a really nice one for encouraging your learners to write at home. They can easily and for free create a newspaper story like ...
ICT in ELT Jo Gakonga: English Teaching Websites
ICT in ELT Jo Gakonga: English Teaching Websites: This site looks as if it's going to be a really useful one. It isn't quite up and running yet, but the idea is that it will be a c...
Wednesday, March 20, 2013
"what you allow you encourage": Week 1: Discussion - Levi Strauss
"what you allow you encourage": Week 1: Discussion - Levi Strauss: Task to be accomplished for BA454 - MANAGEMENT CASES class . Go to www.levistrauss.com/about/vision and read what the company says about ...
Tuesday, March 19, 2013
A CLIL TO CLIMB: The History of the English Language
A CLIL TO CLIMB: The History of the English Language: This is simply astounding. My words aren't needed. Source: Source: Greg
Sunday, March 17, 2013
Friday, March 1, 2013
Thursday, February 28, 2013
Kalinago English: Best-of-ELT-Blog-Posts (Karenne's picks) January ...
Kalinago English: Best-of-ELT-Blog-Posts (Karenne's picks) January ...: What was really "hot" this month Dave Dodgson kicked off a bit of controversy, striking a nerve when he asked why he should have ...
Mad about ELT: Merry Christmas!
Mad about ELT: Merry Christmas!: Thank you all for stopping by, for reading what I feel like saying, for your kind comments here and on Twitter, Facebook and all the places ...
Mad about ELT: Taking your first steps in social networking
Mad about ELT: Taking your first steps in social networking: I really liked this introduction to learning and teaching in the 2.0 era, by Jason T. Bedell. Some of the points he covers: Starting and g...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)